'Gone all in': Paul Merson shares new theory on why Liverpool didn't sign Marc Guehi in January
Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version from Rousing the Kop or go back to LFC Live.
Liverpool Would Have Signed Guehi, But Everyone at Club Trusts Konaté – Merson
Paul Merson has shared a bold theory on why Liverpool opted against signing Marc Guehi from Crystal Palace in the January 2026 transfer window, despite being poised to do so. According to Merson, the Reds had internally agreed to a £30m deal for the England international but pulled back due to unwavering trust in defender Ibrahima Konaté. "Everyone at the club trusts Konaté completely," Merson claimed, emphasizing Liverpool's confidence in their current squad depth amid Konaté's strong form.[1]
The article delves into the transfer saga, revealing Liverpool's keen interest in Guehi under manager Arne Slot and sporting director Richard Hughes. Last summer 2025, a £35m agreement with Palace nearly materialized on deadline day, only for Eagles boss Oliver Glasner to block it without a replacement secured. Lightning struck twice in January when Manchester City swooped in, agreeing a £20m deal amid injuries to City's Josko Gvardiol, Ruben Dias, and John Stones. Fabrizio Romano confirmed the transfer, noting Guehi accepted personal terms.[1][2]
Merson highlights Liverpool's financial caution under FSG, refusing to meet Guehi's contract demands despite readiness to pay Palace's fee. An X account reported Liverpool balked at the player's wage hike. Palace, facing Guehi's contract expiry, capitalized to avoid a free exit.[1][2]
Guehi credited John Stones and Phil Foden for persuading him to join City now over waiting for Liverpool, calling his Anfield move "very close." City's window triumph included beating Liverpool to targets, earning an A+ grade from GOAL for the versatile defender poised for Pep Guardiola's lineup.[2][3]
At Liverpool, faith in Konaté—potentially leaving as a free agent—and squad stability trumped the Guehi pursuit. Merson praises the Reds' long-term vision, suggesting no panic buys despite center-back concerns.[1][3]
(Word count: 298)