'Idiots' - Ex-PL Chief Keith Wyness Drops Verdict on Man United Appointing Michael Carrick Permanently

Former Everton chief executive Keith Wyness has delivered a scathing verdict on Manchester United potentially appointing Michael Carrick as their permanent manager, branding those who would make such a decision as "idiots". Wyness, speaking to Football Insider, dismissed Carrick's suitability despite his strong ties to Old Trafford and impressive work at Middlesbrough in the Championship[1].

The comments come amid United's ongoing search for a new boss following the sacking of Erik ten Hag on October 28 after a 2-1 defeat to West Ham. Ruud van Nistelrooy was installed as interim head coach as the club evaluates options[1]. Carrick, who previously served as interim manager at United and now leads Middlesbrough—currently ninth in the Championship with five wins, three draws, and four losses from 12 games—was initially seen as a contender due to his history under Sir Alex Ferguson and familiarity with the club[1].

However, sources indicate Carrick is no longer among the top targets. Club insider Mike Brown, who assisted Ferguson, explained that while Carrick is highly regarded and "ticks plenty of boxes," United prefers a more experienced top-level manager. No offer is expected at this stage, with the club prioritizing proven elite coaches over internal connections[1].

Wyness echoed this sentiment strongly on October 12, stating: "From what I’ve heard, I don’t see Carrick as the man for them. I don’t see him as the man to take United forward." He criticized the club's leadership, arguing that those at the top lack deep understanding of United's culture and operations, saying: "The people who need to know the club and the way it’s always worked are the people right at the top, and I would argue they don’t know it well and it doesn’t look like they’ve tried to[1].

United continues its process, shifting focus to more seasoned candidates to steady the ship at Old Trafford.

(Word count: 298)