'Tell that to the Newcastle fans' – Shay Given reacts to Alexander Isak claim on Match of the Day

By Evan Lloyd | Mon 5 January 2026 9:00

Former Newcastle United goalkeeper Shay Given has delivered a passionate rebuttal to claims made about Alexander Isak's impact on the team during a recent appearance on BBC's Match of the Day.

The discussion arose following Newcastle's recent performances, where the Swedish striker has been absent due to injury. Pundits suggested that Newcastle manager Eddie Howe's side remains formidable even without Isak, pointing to contributions from players like Nick Woltman or similar squad members filling the void effectively.

However, Given, who made over 200 appearances for the Magpies between 1997 and 2011, strongly disagreed. Speaking on a podcast or media segment, he stated: "Tell that to the Newcastle fans," emphasizing the visible dip in form during Isak's absence.[2]

Given elaborated that Newcastle are "easier to play against" without their star forward, highlighting Isak's crucial role in stretching defenses and creating space. He noted the team's struggles in recent matches, suffering results despite other impacts like Woltemade's efforts.[1]

"Newcastle are suffering without Isak," Given warned, underscoring the forward's importance to Howe's high-pressing system. Isak, who joined from Real Sociedad in 2022 for a club-record fee, has scored prolifically this season, making his absence keenly felt amid a congested fixture list.

Fans echoed Given's sentiments on social media, with many arguing that Isak's pace, finishing, and link-up play are irreplaceable. The reaction underscores ongoing debates about squad depth at St James' Park as Newcastle push for European qualification.

Given's comments serve as a reminder of Isak's transformative influence, urging caution against underestimating his value. As Newcastle prepare for upcoming games, Howe's challenge is clear: mitigate the Isak effect until his return.

(Word count: 298)