Former Liverpool and Aston Villa striker Stan Collymore has expressed strong criticism of Manchester United's decision concerning Marcus Rashford. Collymore believes that United have made a poor deal, suggesting Rashford, at his peak, should have commanded far more than the reported £25 million if Barcelona opts to buy him after his loan spell at Villa. He noted that despite Rashford's underwhelming recent performances, the low potential transfer fee does not justify the investment United made in wages over the years.
Collymore described Rashford’s stint at Villa as underwhelming, saying his cameo appearances were not impressive, contrasting with some overly positive media commentary. He emphasized how Barcelona stand to benefit the most, acquiring a motivated player at a relatively low wage and transfer cost compared to what United might have expected.

The pundit also highlighted ongoing transfer window dynamics at Manchester United, mentioning that one of their best players intends to leave this summer. Manager Ruben Amorim faces challenges as the club reportedly will not strengthen certain problematic areas that were evident in last season’s squad. Simultaneously, Newcastle United's pursuit of a top-class striker could indirectly affect United’s squad strategy, with the Red Devils’ director of recruitment personally interested in that player.
This insight reflects broader tensions and strategic decisions at Manchester United as they navigate both departures and recruitment during an active transfer market period.