John Barnes didn’t hesitate when asked if Kenny Dalglish was a better manager than Graham Taylor
Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version or go back to LFC Live.net.
John Barnes reflects on the similarities and differences between managers Graham Taylor and Kenny Dalglish, highlighting their shared ambition and single-mindedness. He describes both as intensely driven and honest, with Taylor maintaining the same determination throughout his career, similar to Dalglish's approach at Liverpool. Barnes recounts how Taylor was dedicated from his first to last game, and equally single-minded like Dalglish, who unexpectedly left Liverpool despite important fixtures. When Taylor managed England, Barnes notes a more distant relationship with players but insists that the squad was not an unhappy place despite external perceptions. He expresses sympathy for Taylor when results did not favor him, condemning the harsh treatment Taylor received from the media, praising his decency and honesty[1].
Barnes also touches on the evolution in football management, contrasting past managers like Dalglish, who demanded respect and had authority, with today's managers who have to manage players' egos carefully due to their increased power and influence. He notes that contemporary managers face a different challenge where players can significantly impact a manager's job security, unlike in the past when poor form would typically lead to player exclusion rather than managerial dismissal[2].
Regarding his playing career, Barnes credits Graham Taylor as the most important figure in his development, providing the discipline and momentum necessary to reach the top level. He highlights the rigorous training under Taylor at Watford, which forged his success and helped him earn 79 England caps. Barnes also recalls the contrasting football culture at Liverpool under Dalglish compared to Watford, emphasizing the more relaxed environment at Liverpool, which was markedly different from Taylor's authoritative approach in training and tactics[3][5].
Overall, Barnes appreciates Taylor's ambition, integrity, and significant influence on his career, while recognizing the evolving nature of football management and player-manager dynamics over time.
PP