Richard Keys calls for rule change after Newcastle – Liverpool scandal
Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version or go back to LFC Live.net.
Richard Keys has called for a major rule change in the Premier League following Liverpool's dramatic 3-2 victory over Newcastle United on August 25, 2025. Keys highlighted a key issue regarding the actual ball-in-play time during the match, which he revealed was just 40.8%—the lowest recorded in a Premier League game for 15 years. Despite the match lasting over 100 minutes, the proportion of playing time where the ball was active was under half, leading Keys to argue that fans are being "robbed" of actual football action.
In response, Keys proposed implementing a "60-minute ball-in-play clock," shifting the focus from a fixed 90-minute clock to a timing system that would measure only the effective playing time. This would ensure fans watch more continuous, engaging football rather than extended stoppages that prolong matches but reduce action.
The match itself was an instant classic, featuring several dramatic moments: Liverpool took a 2-0 lead through Ryan Gravenberch and Hugo Ekitike before Newcastle’s Bruno Guimaraes and William Osula staged a comeback. Newcastle played much of the second half with ten men after Anthony Gordon's sending off following a VAR review. The game was sealed dramatically by 16-year-old Liverpool substitute Rio Ngumoha, who scored a stunning winner in stoppage time near the 101st minute.
Though Liverpool secured back-to-back wins, some fans and pundits noted tactical concerns, particularly decisions by Liverpool manager Arne Slot. Fans observed a pattern where Ekitike was substituted in all three of Liverpool’s games this season, with opponents scoring soon after his exit. Additionally, Thierry Henry questioned Liverpool's defensive approach before a key free kick that led to Newcastle’s second goal.
Overall, the match highlighted both thrilling football and ongoing debates about game management and rules, with Richard Keys advocating for reforms to enhance the viewing experience by maximizing active playtime.
PP