Casemiro Shines, 3/10 Flops – Man United Player Ratings vs Man City

In a stunning Manchester derby on January 17, 2026, Manchester United secured a 2-0 victory over Manchester City, propelling them up the Premier League table under manager Michael Carrick. The match showcased United's tactical discipline and standout individual performances, while City struggled with inefficiency and key absences.[1][2][5]

Manchester United Player Ratings

Casemiro (9/10) was the midfield maestro, dominating proceedings with tireless energy, crucial interceptions, and precise passing that broke City's lines repeatedly. His leadership anchored United's engine room.[2]

Bruno Fernandes (8.5/10) delivered a derby delight with a goal, pinpoint assists, and visionary playmaking. Captain fantastic orchestrated the win.[2]

Bryan Mbeumo (8/10) and Patrick Dorgu (8/10) shone on the wings, with Mbeumo's pace troubling City's defense and Dorgu netting the opener via a clinical finish.[2][5]

Michael Carrick's system clicked perfectly, with solid defending from the backline earning 7s across the board. Goalkeeper earned a steady 7 for key saves.[2]

Manchester City Flops (3/10s)

Erling Haaland (3/10) was anonymous once more, missing chances and fading against United's press—his form slump continues to haunt City's title hopes.[4]

Three defenders rated 3/10 for positional errors leading to both goals, exposed by United's counters. Midfield lacked creativity.[1][3]

Despite Gigi Donnarumma's heroics (7.5/10) in goal, including stunning saves, City couldn't salvage the derby. Rico Lewis (4/10) and others faltered.[1][4]

United's win, built on Carrick's "cracked it" tactics, boosts morale ahead of a title push, while City lick wounds from this battering.[2][5] (Word count: 298)