Darke's Premier League Flops So Far: Isak, Sesko, Gittens Lead the Way

In his latest ESPN analysis, commentator Ian Darke highlights the Premier League's biggest underperformers midway through the 2025-26 season, focusing on high-profile signings and stars who have failed to deliver. Leading the list is Alexander Isak, now at Liverpool after a £125 million transfer from Newcastle. Despite high expectations, Isak has been a shadow of his former self, short on rhythm due to a pre-move strike, and suffered a broken leg against Tottenham on December 20, limiting him further[2].

Benjamin Sesko, the ex-RB Leipzig striker at Arsenal, has struggled with just one goal, lacking the clinical edge needed despite his promising pedigree. Darke notes his adjustment to the Premier League's intensity has been tough[2]. Similarly, Jamie Gittens, the former Dortmund winger now at Manchester City, has started only four league games, overshadowed by Pedro Neto, Alejandro Garnacho, and Estêvão[2].

Other notable flops include Thierno Barry at Everton, who has one goal despite an 11-goal LaLiga season at Villarreal; fans appreciate his work rate, but he needs to convert chances[2]. Jorgen Strand Larsen of Wolves has managed just one goal in 15 appearances after 14 last term, amid accusations he wants out as Wolves languish with two points from 18 games[2]. Goalkeeper James Trafford, signed by City as No. 1, has been benched after Gianluigi Donnarumma's arrival from PSG, stalling his England World Cup hopes[2].

Xavi Simons at Tottenham has disappointed post-Leipzig, offering cameos like a solo goal against Brentford but appearing lightweight in physical battles without James Maddison[2]. Darke contextualizes these amid broader team struggles, echoing past flops like Phil Foden's form dip or Rasmus Højlund's United woes[3][4]. He hopes for rebounds, noting the season's early stage leaves room for recovery, much like City's past resurgences[1].

(Word count: 298)