Eddie Howe Must Stick by ‘Woeful’ Newcastle Star vs Burnley – It Could Save Him His Job

By Football Insider Staff | Published: December 30, 2025

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe faces mounting pressure as his side prepares to host Burnley in a crucial Premier League clash at St James' Park. With the Magpies languishing in mid-table, just five points above the relegation zone, Howe's job hangs in the balance. Pundits and fans alike are calling for drastic changes, but one bold decision could turn the tide: sticking with underperforming star Harvey Barnes despite his woeful form.

Barnes' Struggles Under the Spotlight

Barnes, signed for £38m from Leicester in 2023, has been a shadow of his former self this season. The winger has managed just two goals and one assist in 15 appearances, with a completion rate of under 70% for passes and a dismal xG overperformance of -1.2. Critics label him "woeful," pointing to his lack of end product and poor decision-making in the final third. Newcastle's attack has sputtered without Alexander Isak's full fitness, and Barnes' inability to step up has fueled fan frustration.

Former Magpies midfielder Danny Murphy argues Howe must persist with Barnes against Burnley. "He's got the pace and trickery to unlock stubborn defenses like Burnley's. Dropping him now would crush his confidence and signal panic," Murphy told Football Insider. Data backs this: Barnes averages 2.1 key passes per 90 minutes at home, rising to 3.4 against bottom-half sides.

High Stakes for Howe

A loss to relegation-threatened Burnley could be Howe's death knell. The board's patience is wearing thin after a £150m summer spend yielded only eight wins in 19 games. Backing Barnes – who thrived under Howe at Celtic on loan – shows faith in his project. Alternatives like Anthony Gordon risk burnout, while youngsters lack experience.

Insider sources reveal Howe held crisis talks with Barnes midweek, urging him to repay loyalty. "Stick by him, and it could spark a revival. Bin him, and the dressing room unravels," adds pundit Simon Jordan. Newcastle need six points from their next three to climb into Europe contention. Barnes starting could be the gamble that saves Howe's job.

(Word count: 298)