Keith Hackett Stunned by Kevin Clancy Controversy After Footage from Hearts Win vs St Mirren

Former FIFA official Keith Hackett has expressed shock over referee Kevin Clancy's handling of a controversial incident during Hearts' victory against St Mirren. Newly released footage has reignited debate, prompting Hackett to criticize Clancy's initial decision-making on the pitch.[2]

The controversy centers on Hearts midfielder Beni Baningime, who received a red card in the match. Hackett argues that Clancy should have sent Baningime off originally, rather than after reviewing footage. "Kevin Clancy should have originally sent off Beni Baningime," Hackett stated bluntly, adding that few Hearts fans would dispute the eventual dismissal given the evidence.[2]

Hackett, a respected voice in football officiating, described the situation as stunning, highlighting how post-match analysis exposed Clancy's oversight. The ex-PGMOL chief emphasized the importance of real-time judgment, suggesting Clancy missed clear dangerous play that warranted immediate action. This incident adds to growing scrutiny of Clancy's performances in Scottish football, where VAR interventions have frequently overturned or confirmed his calls.[1][2]

Similar issues have plagued Clancy in recent games. In Hearts' win over Dundee, he faced backlash for a red card to Mo Sylla, which Hackett called "really interesting," underscoring patterns in high-stakes matches.[1] St Mirren clashes have also seen Clancy at the center of VAR disputes, including disallowed goals and penalties, fueling fan frustration across divisions.[4][6]

Hackett's intervention underscores broader concerns about referee consistency in the SPFL. As a former top official, his verdict carries weight, calling for better preparation and instincts to avoid reliance on technology. Hearts secured the points despite the drama, but the episode has left Clancy's reputation under fire, with calls for retrospective SFA review.[2]

(Word count: 298)