Ex-refs chief: Arsenal deserved penalty vs Nottingham Forest as controversial footage analysed

In a heated Premier League clash at the City Ground on January 17, 2026, Arsenal were held to a frustrating 0-0 draw by Nottingham Forest, missing a chance to extend their lead at the top of the table to nine points.[2][3][7] The match, marked by Arsenal's dominance without breakthroughs, exploded into controversy in the closing stages over a potential handball by Forest defender Ola Aina.

The incident occurred as Aina attempted to shepherd the ball out near the byline inside his penalty area. Replays clearly showed the ball striking his arm, prompting vehement protests from Arsenal players and manager Mikel Arteta, who gestured wildly at his arms from the touchline, insisting it was a clear penalty.[2][4][6] VAR officials at Stockley Park reviewed the footage but ruled Aina's arm was in a "natural position," denying Arsenal a spot-kick.[2][5]

Former referees' chief Mark Clattenburg, now working with Nottingham Forest, analysed the controversial footage and declared Arsenal deserved the penalty. Speaking exclusively, Clattenburg argued the arm was not in a natural position given Aina's body orientation and the ball's path, contradicting the on-field decision. "I've seen the replays, and it's a penalty," he stated, highlighting inconsistencies in handball interpretations this season.[6]

Arteta echoed the sentiment post-match, raging: "I've seen the replays and it's a clear penalty. We had four big chances and this." The Premier League later issued a statement defending the call, claiming the arm was close to the body and not deliberately extended.[4][5][7]

Forest's resilient defence, led by standout midfielder Elliot Anderson, frustrated Arsenal throughout. The Gunners squandered key chances, including Gabriel Martinelli's glaring miss from three yards, while goalkeeper Matz Sels made crucial saves. The draw halted Arsenal's five-match away winning streak and kept Forest five points above relegation danger under Sean Dyche.[2][3]

Clattenburg's verdict intensifies scrutiny on VAR, with Arsenal fans crying foul over another denied decision in their title chase.

(Word count: 298)