Ex-refs chief: Chris Kavanagh to blame as Man City star could have seen red vs Newcastle

Former PGMOL head Keith Hackett has slammed referee Chris Kavanagh's performance in Newcastle United's Carabao Cup semi-final first leg against Manchester City at St James' Park. Hackett, a vocal critic of Kavanagh this 2025-26 season, highlighted three disastrous decisions that frustrated fans from both sides[1].

Joelinton's studs-up challenge on Phil Foden

Early in the match, Newcastle's Joelinton made a late, studs-up tackle on Man City's Phil Foden as he played out from defense. Kavanagh waved play on without a card, despite the challenge's recklessness. Joelinton was later booked for an off-the-ball incident, amplifying frustrations over inconsistent officiating[1].

Nico O'Reilly's lucky escape

Man City's young midfielder Nico O'Reilly lashed out at Joelinton, making clear contact with the back of the Newcastle player's head while jostling for space. The limited but deliberate contact warranted a red card, yet Kavanagh kept his cards pocketed, allowing O'Reilly to stay on. Hackett argued this was a missed sending-off[1].

Botched offside call denies Man City goal

In the 63rd minute, Man City's substitute Semenyo flicked in a corner, seemingly doubling the lead. After a prolonged VAR review, the goal was disallowed for Erling Haaland's offside position. Critics called it the season's worst decision: Haaland had no realistic chance to interfere with Newcastle keeper Nick Pope, who was beaten from close range. Kavanagh's involvement drew further ire[1].

Adding context, Newcastle fans were already fuming pre-match over Kavanagh's appointment, given his Manchester roots and strong records with both teams—no red cards for either in prior games. Newcastle hold a slight edge in their history under him (15 wins in 33 matches vs City's 9 in 15)[2]. Hackett's critique underscores ongoing refereeing controversies in English football[1].

(Word count: 298)