Ex-Refs Chief: James Garner Should Have Been Sent Off in Major Incident vs Aston Villa

In a heated Premier League clash at Villa Park on Sunday, January 18, 2026, Everton secured a vital victory over Aston Villa, but the match was overshadowed by a controversial non-call involving Everton midfielder James Garner. Former FIFA-listed referee Keith Hackett, ex-head of referees, launched a scathing critique of the officiating, insisting Garner deserved a second yellow card and subsequent red card for a blatant push on Aston Villa's Morgan Rogers[1][3][4].

The incident occurred late in the game as Villa pushed for an equalizer, with Everton already leading 3-0 thanks to goals including one from Thierno Barry. Garner, already on a yellow, shoved Rogers in the back just outside the penalty area. Hackett, speaking exclusively, called it "a clear push on his opponent and a challenge that should have received a yellow card. He should have seen red, this is a nailed-on second yellow. What’s the referee thinking?"[1]. Sky Sports footage highlighted the moment, questioning if Garner was lucky to escape punishment[3][4].

Despite the uproar, Aston Villa's performance drew criticism. Unai Emery's side was described as toothless, barely threatening Everton keeper Jordan Pickford, and underestimating David Moyes' gritty Toffees. Even with a potential red card, Villa's lackluster display might not have changed the outcome, as Everton could have shifted defensive[1]. Post-match, Garner himself noted, "The lads ground it out today, we got the chance and we took it," denting Villa's title aspirations[2].

Hackett's comments reignite debates on refereeing standards, but Villa must refocus on securing Champions League spots rather than dwelling on the decision. The loss leaves Emery's men needing a swift turnaround, while Everton revel in a crucial three points[1].

(Word count: 298)