Darke's Premier League Flops So Far: Isak, Sesko, Gittens Lead the Way

In his latest ESPN column, Ian Darke highlights the Premier League's biggest underperformers midway through the 2025-26 season, focusing on high-profile stars who have disappointed despite lofty expectations. Alexander Isak tops the list after his record £125 million move from Newcastle to Liverpool. Even before a broken leg sidelined him until March following a goal against Tottenham, Isak struggled with rhythm after a pre-transfer strike, appearing a shadow of his former self[2][5].

Benjamin Sesko, Arsenal's big summer signing, has also flopped. The ex-Dortmund youngster has started just four Premier League games, overtaken by Pedro Neto, Alejandro Garnacho, and Estêvão in the pecking order[2]. Darke notes his limited impact despite the hype.

Jamie Gittens rounds out the leading trio, enduring a tough adaptation at his new club—likely Manchester United or another side—where he's failed to break through amid competition[2].

Other notable flops include Thierno Barry at Everton, who has just one goal despite an 11-goal LaLiga season prior; fans appreciate his work rate, but he lacks clinical finishing[2]. Milos Kerkez, Liverpool's £40 million left-back replacement for Andy Robertson, has struggled, briefly losing his place amid the team's woes before regaining it[2].

Jorgen Strand Larsen has been a disaster at Wolverhampton Wanderers, scoring once in 15 games after 14 last season, including a missed penalty; rumors swirl he wants out as Wolves languish with two points from 18 games[2]. Darke draws parallels to past flops like Rasmus Højlund (three goals in 27 for United) and Phil Foden (lost mojo at City), hoping these players rebound[3].

Darke emphasizes context—transfers, injuries, team struggles—but urges improvement ahead of 2025-26's second half. Liverpool's massive spends on attackers like Isak have backfired so far, mirroring broader disappointments[5]. (Word count: 298)