Grading Premier League 'Big Six' after 10 games: Arsenal an A; Liverpool a D

Grading the Premier League 'Big Six' After 10 Games: Arsenal Excel, Liverpool Flounder

With 10 games completed in the 2025-26 Premier League season, Arsenal have emerged as the standout team, earning an "A" grade for their impressive start. The Gunners top the table with 8 wins, 1 draw, and just 1 loss, amassing 25 points—6 clear of their closest rivals—and boasting a league-leading goal difference of +15[1][2]. Arsenal's dominant defense, conceding only 3 goals in 10 matches, has been a cornerstone of their success, and their attacking play continues to impress, suggesting a team firing on all cylinders and looking every bit the title contender[1].

Manchester City, the defending champions, are in second place with 6 wins, 1 draw, and 3 losses for 19 points. While not as commanding as in past seasons, their firepower and depth keep them firmly in the hunt, though defensive vulnerabilities have occasionally cost them points. City remains a major threat, especially as the season progresses and new signings settle in.

Liverpool, traditionally among the league's elite, have underwhelmed compared to Arsenal and Man City, earning a "D" grade for their mixed results. The Reds sit third (along with Sunderland and Bournemouth—all tied on 18 points) with 6 wins and 4 losses, showing inconsistency in both attack and defense[1][2]. Despite flashes of quality, their defense has been leaky, and their tendency to concede at critical moments in games has left fans frustrated. Liverpool's form raises questions about their title credentials this year.

The rest of the "Big Six" clubs have also experienced mixed fortunes. Chelsea, Tottenham, and Manchester United are all locked on 17 points, with Chelsea and Tottenham showing glimpses of potential but also suffering from inconsistency[1]. Manchester United, in particular, have struggled for fluency despite their points haul, with a goal difference of just +1 highlighting their difficulty in dominating opponents.

Arsenal's early-season surge has set the tone for the campaign, establishing them as the team to beat. Manchester City, while not at their best, remain dangerous. Liverpool, by contrast, must quickly regroup if they are to avoid falling further behind in the title race. As the Premier League heads into winter, the fortunes of these clubs—especially those trying to bridge the gap to Arsenal—will be crucial in shaping the outcome of one of the most competitive seasons in recent memory[1].