Jamie Carragher explains why Diego Simeone would be a problem for Man Utd

Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version from Mirror or go back to LFC Live.

I cannot access the specific Mirror article you've linked. However, I can provide a summary based on the search results available, which cover Jamie Carragher's analysis of Diego Simeone as a Manchester United managerial candidate.

Jamie Carragher's Analysis: Why Diego Simeone Doesn't Fit Manchester United

Jamie Carragher, appearing on Sky Sports' Monday Night Football, recently evaluated Diego Simeone as a potential manager for Manchester United and concluded he would be unsuitable for the role[1]. While acknowledging Simeone's impressive track record and longevity at Atlético Madrid, Carragher identified a fundamental mismatch between the Argentine manager's philosophy and the club's identity[1][3].

The core issue, according to Carragher, centers on playing style. Manchester United's DNA is built on attacking football, whereas Simeone is fundamentally a defensive manager[1]. This philosophical divergence represents a significant obstacle to a successful partnership between the manager and the club.

Carragher's concerns reflect broader questions about Manchester United's direction. Thierry Henry, joining the discussion, highlighted the club's lack of clarity, stating it remains unclear what kind of team United wants to be or what their true DNA actually is[1].

Despite these reservations, some have suggested Simeone could bring positive attributes to Old Trafford. An ex-Premier League player has argued that Simeone would have Manchester United "working like mad dogs," performing with relentless energy and demanding excellence[2]. However, Carragher's four-man shortlist for the summer managerial search—Julian Nagelsmann, Thomas Tuchel, Luis Enrique, and Eddie Howe—excluded Simeone entirely[1].

In his final assessment, Carragher suggested that while ideally everyone would prefer Luis Enrique, Thomas Tuchel is realistically the most likely candidate to take the Manchester United position[1].