Jamie Redknapp Shares New Theory After Antoine Semenyo to Liverpool Howler

By Liverpool.com Staff | Published January 14, 2026

Former Liverpool midfielder Jamie Redknapp has sparked debate with a bold new theory following Bournemouth's Antoine Semenyo's glaring miss against Liverpool in their recent Premier League clash. The 25-year-old forward, who has been heavily linked with a move to Anfield amid Liverpool's search for attacking reinforcements, fluffed a golden opportunity late in the game, preserving a 2-1 victory for the Reds at the Vitality Stadium.

Speaking on Sky Sports, Redknapp suggested that Semenyo's "howler" – a sliced shot from six yards out – might actually be a subconscious act of sabotage. "Look, Semenyo's got everything: pace, power, finishing ability. He's been banging on doors for a big move. But that miss? It screamed Liverpool fan," Redknapp quipped. "Maybe deep down, he didn't want to ruin his dream transfer by knocking out his future employers. It's the kind of psychological block you see in players desperate for a switch."

The theory gained traction online, with fans memeing Semenyo's shank as "the worst/best miss of the season." Redknapp elaborated, drawing parallels to past transfer sagas: "Remember Andy Carroll scoring against us before joining? Or Luis Suarez's antics? Pressure plays mind games. Liverpool scouts were there – Semenyo knew it. That hesitation? Pure Anfield destiny."

Bournemouth boss Andoni Iraola dismissed the idea post-match, calling it "nonsense," while praising Semenyo's overall display. Semenyo himself laughed it off on Instagram: "Missed? Nah, just practicing my drama skills for Hollywood 😂 #LFC."

Liverpool, sitting top of the table, continue monitoring the Ghana international, whose 8 goals this season have alerted Arne Slot. Redknapp's take adds intrigue: is Semenyo subconsciously wearing the No.9 shirt already? As the January window heats up, this viral theory underscores the fine line between blunder and brilliance in the transfer market.

Key Takeaways:

• Semenyo's miss preserved Liverpool's win.
• Redknapp's theory: Self-sabotage for transfer hopes.
• Fans and pundits divided on the "fanboy fail."

(Word count: 298)