Keith Hackett Makes His Feelings Clear Over John Stones Penalty Claim in Man City vs Salford City

By Football Insider Staff | Published recently

Former top referee Keith Hackett has strongly backed the decision to award a penalty against Manchester City defender John Stones during their match against Salford City, describing it as "clear-cut" after reviewing key footage. Hackett, a respected ex-FIFA official, analyzed BBC footage that he says exposes Stones' handball infringement, leaving no room for debate.[2]

In a heated encounter, Stones was adjudged to have handled the ball in the penalty area, prompting Salford's successful spot-kick claim. Hackett praised the on-field referee's call, stating, “I think he was right in regards to John Stones, the penalty kick that was awarded against him.” He emphasized that the incident was unmistakable upon close inspection, urging consistency in such rulings across leagues.[2]

The controversy echoes recent Premier League drama involving Stones, such as his dramatic late header against Wolves, initially ruled out for Bernardo Silva's offside interference before being awarded following VAR review. In that case, Silva nudged goalkeeper Jose Sa but moved away just before Stones' connection, allowing referee Michael Kavanagh to overturn the decision as Sa retained a clear line of sight.[1]

Hackett's intervention highlights ongoing debates over VAR and refereeing standards in English football. He has previously pushed for rule changes post-Man City-Wolves, advocating clearer guidelines on offside and interference to reduce controversy.[3] For Man City vs Salford City, Hackett's verdict shuts down claims of soft penalties, insisting Stones was "caught red-handed."

City manager Pep Guardiola reportedly expressed frustration post-match, but Hackett dismissed any sympathy, reinforcing that the laws of the game were correctly applied. This ruling adds to City's challenging season, amid injury concerns for stars like Erling Haaland and Stones himself.[3]

(Word count: 298)