Liverpool legend warns against Xabi Alonso appointment as Real Madrid theory dismissed

Liverpool Legend Steve Nicol Warns Against Xabi Alonso Appointment as Real Madrid Theory Dismissed

Liverpool icon Steve Nicol has cautioned the club against pursuing Xabi Alonso as a potential replacement for Arne Slot, dismissing rumors linking the Spaniard to Anfield following his recent departure from Real Madrid. In a heated ESPN FC discussion, Nicol labeled the idea of hiring Alonso as "completely stupid," arguing that his tactical style and recent failures make him an ill fit for the Reds.[2][6]

Alonso's tenure at Real Madrid ended abruptly by mutual consent after just months in charge, amid mounting pressure and poor results, including a 3-2 loss to Barcelona in the Spanish Super Cup final.[1][3][4] ESPN analysts noted the timing was surprising, with doubts about Alonso's fit plaguing the club from the start. He replaced Carlo Ancelotti, who moved to manage Brazil, but struggled to implement his preferred 3-4-3 system despite signings like center-back Dean Huijsen and plans for wing-backs, potentially including Trent Alexander-Arnold.[1] Alonso had envisioned Jude Bellingham as a central midfielder, not a false nine, but inefficiencies persisted.[1]

Real Madrid quickly appointed former player Álvaro Arbeloa as manager, with club statements omitting "interim," suggesting a longer-term role. Analysts debated Arbeloa's ability to handle big personalities in the dressing room after seven successful seasons as a player, winning eight trophies.[3][4]

Meanwhile, Nicol questioned Liverpool's direction under Slot after their FA Cup victory, but firmly opposed Alonso's return. "If I'm picking, no way," he stated, citing Alonso's "huge pressure" at Madrid and lack of success.[2][3][6] Liverpool fans, per polls, speculate Alonso could still join Anfield post-sacking, but Nicol dismissed any "Real Madrid theory" tying Alonso's exit to a Liverpool move.[5][6]

The debate underscores divided opinions: while Alonso's pedigree shines, his Madrid flop raises red flags for Premier League suitors like Liverpool, where Slot's project faces scrutiny.[1][2]

(Word count: 298)