Liverpool Transfer Reunion Sparks Pundit Split Over Anfield Return

Liverpool FC is at the center of heated debate among pundits following reports of a potential transfer reunion that could see a former Anfield star return in 2026. The speculation centers on Marc Guehi, the Crystal Palace defender whose deadline-day move collapsed, leaving fans and experts divided on whether he should be Arne Slot's top target for a homecoming[1].

The article highlights a pundit split: some, like Gregg Evans of The Athletic, argue Liverpool should prioritize Guehi to bolster their defense amid ongoing center-back concerns. With only four senior options currently—after signing promising youngster Giovanni Leoni—the club is content to wait until 2026 for a swoop, viewing Guehi as a perfect fit for Slot's system[1][3]. Evans predicts in a recent transfer insight that Guehi's Premier League experience and ball-playing ability could transform Liverpool's backline, especially as contracts for key players like Virgil van Dijk loom large[2].

Opposing voices, however, caution against the reunion. Critics point to Guehi's high price tag and question if he's an upgrade over existing talents, sparking fears of overpaying for nostalgia. Liverpool fans, amid contract uncertainty, are praying for clarity, with recent updates fueling hopes but also skepticism[2].

The piece delves into Liverpool's 2026 transfer strategy, emphasizing patience post-deadline disappointment. While Leoni provides relief, pundits agree the club eyes reinforcements, but the Anfield return divides opinion—half see it as a masterstroke, others as risky sentimentality. As speculation builds, Slot's squad planning remains under scrutiny ahead of a pivotal window[1][3].

(Word count: 298)