Monday Night Club: Arsenal’s Wobble, the Case for Carrick & Are Liverpool 'Soft'?

Mark Chapman hosts the latest Monday Night Club on BBC Radio 5 Live, joined by pundits Chris Sutton, Rory Smith, and Andros Townsend, dissecting key Premier League talking points on January 26, 2026.[4][5]

Arsenal’s Wobble After Man Utd Shock

The show kicks off with Manchester United’s stunning victory over Arsenal, putting the Gunners' title aspirations under scrutiny. Pundits highlight Arsenal's **nerves** amid a recent dip in form, questioning their ability to maintain a top-four push. Chris Sutton analyzes defensive lapses, while Rory Smith points to tactical vulnerabilities exposed by United's counter-attacks. Andros Townsend, drawing from his playing experience, warns of the psychological toll of such setbacks.[5]

The Case for Michael Carrick at Manchester United

A major focus is Michael Carrick’s promising start as Man Utd manager. Following his first game in charge—referenced from prior discussions—experts build a compelling argument for his long-term role. Sutton praises Carrick's calm authority and youth development ethos, contrasting it with past managerial instability. Smith notes strategic signings and fan support, suggesting Carrick could stabilize the club amid recent chaos.[2]

Are Liverpool 'Soft'? Mental Resilience in Question

The panel debates whether Liverpool lack toughness ('soft'), especially after recent high-profile losses. Townsend recounts heated atmospheres like Tottenham's, where crowd pressure tests mentality, implying Liverpool falter under scrutiny. Sutton references explosive incidents, like post-AFCON final scenes, to argue for improved grit. Smith counters with data on their attacking prowess but concedes away form issues.[2]

Other Highlights

• Managerial Pressures: Tense situations at Tottenham (Thomas Frank) and Crystal Palace (Oliver Glasner), with fan boos echoing at Spurs Stadium.[2]
• Lower League Buzz: Sunderland's rise with Granit Xhaka, Bournemouth's starts, and Wolves' Vitor Pereira facing ire—echoing broader trends.[1]
• Personal Stories: Townsend on Thai football life; Sutton's Inter Milan tales; Scottish football insights.[1]

The lively discussion, available on BBC Sounds and iPlayer, blends sharp analysis with anecdotes, underscoring a chaotic Premier League season. (298 words)