Newcastle United vs Man City Ref Watch: Three Decisions Chris Kavanagh Got Disastrously Wrong

In a highly contentious Premier League clash between Newcastle United and Manchester City, referee Chris Kavanagh drew sharp criticism for three pivotal decisions that allegedly swung the match. Appointed as the match official, Kavanagh's performance has been dissected by fans and pundits alike[1].

1. Haaland's Disallowed Goal – A VAR Nightmare

The first flashpoint came when Manchester City's Erling Haaland appeared to score a crucial equalizer. Initially flagged offside, VAR prompted Kavanagh to review at the pitchside monitor. Despite minimal interference, he ruled Haaland had impeded Newcastle defender Fabian Schär's ability to play the ball, disallowing the goal[2]. Critics argue the contact was negligible, accusing Kavanagh of over-interpreting the laws in City's favor—or lack thereof—robbing City of momentum. Pundits labeled it a "disastrous" call, with replays showing Haaland barely touched Schär.

2. Missed Newcastle Penalty – Clear Handball Ignored

Early in the second half, Newcastle's Alexander Isak drove into the box, only for a City defender's arm to deflect a shot. Kavanagh waved play on, dismissing appeals despite the ball striking an outstretched arm from close range. No VAR intervention followed, leaving Magpies furious. Analysis suggests it met handball criteria under IFAB guidelines, branding Kavanagh's inaction as inexplicably lenient.

3. Incorrect Red Card to Newcastle's Botman

The game's turning point: Newcastle's Sven Botman tackled Haaland aggressively but fairly. Kavanagh brandished a straight red, later partially rescinded by VAR to yellow, but the initial error disrupted Newcastle's defense for minutes. Supporters called it "disastrously wrong," arguing no excessive force was evident.

These blunders overshadowed a thrilling 2-1 City win, fueling debates on Kavanagh's competence. Newcastle manager Eddie Howe demanded better officiating, while City rued the lost goal. (298 words)