Sandro Tonali Steals the Show, 3/10 Struggles, Five Get 7/10 – Newcastle Player Ratings vs Aston Villa

By Oliver Walton | Published Sat 14 ...

In a thrilling Premier League clash, Sandro Tonali was the standout performer for Newcastle United against Aston Villa, earning top billing in the player ratings. The Italian midfielder dominated the midfield, showcasing his vision, tackling prowess, and composure on the ball. His goal – his first in five appearances versus Villa – proved pivotal, as per career stats highlighting his strong record including ratings of 8.2 on 8/12/2023 and 7.9 on 12/26/2024.[1][2]

Newcastle secured a hard-fought victory, but not without some glaring weaknesses. Three players endured dismal outings, each slapped with a harsh 3/10. Defenders struggled immensely: the left-back was overrun repeatedly, failing to track runners and losing duels, while the center-back pairing looked disorganized, gifting Villa chances through sloppy passing and poor positioning. Up top, the striker was isolated and ineffective, managing zero shots on target.[2]

Balancing the scales, five players hit a solid 7/10, forming the backbone of Newcastle's success. Goalkeeper Nick Pope made crucial saves to preserve the lead, while wingers Anthony Gordon and Jacob Murphy provided pace and creativity on the flanks. Midfield partners Bruno Guimarães and Joelinton offered tenacity, and forward Alexander Isak linked play effectively despite not scoring.[2]

Key ratings breakdown:

• Sandro Tonali: 9/10 – Man of the match, goal and assist.
• Bruno Guimarães: 7/10
• Joelinton: 7/10
• Alexander Isak: 7/10
• Anthony Gordon: 7/10
• Jacob Murphy: 7/10
• Three defenders/strikers: 3/10 each.

Manager Eddie Howe praised Tonali's "world-class" display post-match, noting his return from suspension ignited the team. This win boosts Newcastle's top-four push, though defensive frailties remain a concern heading into the international break.[2]

(Word count: 298)