Bukayo Saka or Mo Salah? Explaining Why Theo Walcott's Liverpool Claim Doesn't Stand Up to Scrutiny

Former Arsenal winger Theo Walcott recently sparked debate by claiming that Arsenal's Bukayo Saka would start ahead of Liverpool's Mo Salah in a hypothetical Liverpool lineup. This opinion piece dissects Walcott's assertion, arguing it lacks substance given Salah's proven track record and current form.[1]

Walcott, speaking on a podcast, suggested Saka's versatility and youth make him the superior choice for Liverpool's right-wing spot. He praised Saka as the "number one" Premier League talent, even ranking him above Manchester City's Phil Foden.[3] However, the article counters that neither Salah nor Liverpool have had a flawless 2026 season, yet Salah's contributions remain unmatched.[1]

Salah's Enduring Excellence

At 33, Salah continues to dominate, boasting superior goal tallies, assists, and big-game performances compared to Saka. The piece highlights Salah's consistency in the Premier League and Champions League, where he has carried Liverpool through tough stretches. Saka, while brilliant for Arsenal, hasn't matched Salah's output in high-pressure fixtures or trophy hauls.[1]

• Goals & Assists: Salah leads Saka lifetime in both metrics, even accounting for age difference.
• Trophies: Salah's multiple Premier League and Champions League wins dwarf Saka's accolades.
• Versatility: Salah adapts seamlessly; Saka thrives mainly on the right flank.[1]

Walcott's Bias Exposed

The article questions Walcott's objectivity as an ex-Arsenal player, noting his history of hyping Gunners stars like Saka while downplaying rivals. References to Walcott's past comments on players like Romeo Lavia and Nathan Tella underscore his pattern of Arsenal favoritism.[2][4] Liverpool's system, built around Salah's pace and finishing, wouldn't bench him for Saka's potential alone.[1]

In conclusion, Walcott's claim is simplistic and wrong. Salah's experience, stats, and impact make him indispensable. Saka is a star, but replacing Salah is fantasy football, not reality.[1]

(Word count: 298)