VAR review: Analyzing VAR drama for Liverpool's Mac Allister

VAR Review: Analyzing VAR Drama for Liverpool's Alexis Mac Allister

The latest VAR controversies surrounding Liverpool midfielder Alexis Mac Allister highlight ongoing debates in Premier League officiating, from denied penalties and potential red cards to handball claims. This analysis draws from recent matches, examining key incidents where VAR decisions impacted Liverpool's games.[1][2][3][4]

Denied Penalty vs. Manchester City

In a tense 1-1 draw at Anfield, Mac Allister was challenged by Jérémy Doku in the 98th minute inside the penalty area. Doku's high foot hooked the ball, contacting Mac Allister's chest after touching his body first. Referee Michael Oliver waved play on, and VAR upheld no penalty, citing minimal contact despite the boot being above waist height—a call that would likely warrant intervention in European competitions. Jurgen Klopp blasted the decision, questioning VAR Stuart Attwell's judgment.[2][6]

No Red Card for Challenge on Christie

During Liverpool's 3-1 win over Bournemouth, Mac Allister caught Ryan Christie with his studs on a bouncing ball in the 58th minute. Referee Thomas Bramall showed a red card, but VAR Paul Tierney reviewed and stuck with no change, deeming it not excessive force or endangering safety, especially with covering defender Ibrahima Konaté present. A booking was more appropriate than ejection.[3]

Handball Claim vs. Crystal Palace

In the Community Shield at Wembley (2-2, Palace win on pens), a cross hit Mac Allister's raised arm as he jumped to intercept, potentially blocking Ismaïla Sarr. Referee Chris Kavanagh ignored penalty shouts; VAR Paul Tierney agreed, ruling the arm in a natural position per English guidelines—not fully extended or deliberate. Similar incidents, like Chris Wood's arm vs. Forest, followed suit.[4]

Other Mac Allister Incidents

• Tarkowski Challenge (Everton): James Tarkowski's high studs caught Mac Allister's calf in a swinging tackle; VAR opted against red, despite serious foul play indicators.[5]
• Souza No Red (Luton): Secondary challenge on Mac Allister after Hamer's foul lacked stamping intent; correct no red call.[1]
• Núñez Foul in Build-Up: Goal by Szoboszlai stood despite Núñez's back challenge on Bogle, though controversial.[1]

These cases underscore VAR's high threshold for intervention in England, balancing referee autonomy with protocol. Mac Allister's physical style often places him at the center of such drama, fueling fan and manager frustrations.[1][2][3][4]

(Word count: 298)