Wolves vs Arsenal Ref Watch: Three Decisions Paul Tierney Got Wrong at Molineux

Paul Tierney refereed Arsenal's 2-2 draw against Wolves at Molineux, a match where Arsenal took an early lead through Bukayo Saka's goal in the first five minutes, latching onto Declan Rice’s cross for his fifth league strike of the season. Despite the excitement, Football Insider highlighted three key decisions Tierney mishandled, contributing to a frustrating night for the Gunners.[1]

1. Piero Hincapie’s Simulation Should Have Earned a Booking

On the stroke of half-time, Arsenal appealed for a penalty as Bayer Leverkusen loanee Piero Hincapie went down in the Wolves box under challenge from Andre. Replays confirmed minimal contact—not enough for a spot-kick, correctly waved away by Tierney. However, Hincapie’s theatrical dive warranted a yellow card for simulation and a free-kick to Wolves, but Tierney opted to play on, missing a clear opportunity to caution the Ecuadorian.[1]

2. Adam Armstrong’s Reckless Head-First Challenge on Gabriel

Tierney issued just two yellow cards all game, but Wolves striker Adam Armstrong escaped punishment in the 86th minute. The former Southampton forward lunged head-first into Arsenal defender Gabriel Magalhães while chasing the ball, leaving the Brazilian writhing in pain. This overly rough challenge clearly merited a yellow card, yet Tierney kept his cards pocketed, allowing Armstrong to avoid sanction.[1]

Additional Context and Tierney’s Record

The match, played on February 18, 2026, at Molineux, was Tierney's first Arsenal game in two seasons following an injury hiatus. With VAR Michael Salisbury assisting, Arsenal's mixed history under Tierney includes 10 wins, five draws, and six losses, plus controversies like red cards and penalties. Despite the draw, Saka's form shines, with speculation on records he could break post-contract.[1][2][3]

These errors underscored Tierney’s leniency, potentially costing Arsenal in a tightly contested Premier League clash.