Worse than Anthony Gordon: Eddie Howe must finally axe ‘dreadful’ Newcastle flop vs Crystal Palace

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe faces a critical decision ahead of their Premier League clash with Crystal Palace on Sunday, January 4, 2026, at St. James' Park. The Football Insider article demands that Howe drop a "dreadful" underperforming player deemed even worse than winger Anthony Gordon, who has struggled this season[1][2].

Newcastle sit strongly in the table after a 3-1 victory over Burnley on December 30, 2025, boosting their top-four aspirations and Champions League hopes. Fixtures confirm the Palace game as a Sky Sports broadcast at 3pm, following holiday wins against Manchester United and a draw with Chelsea[1][2]. Crystal Palace, meanwhile, have tailed off after a promising 2025, making this a key opportunity for the Magpies[5].

The article's focal point is a specific "flop" – a high-profile signing failing to justify his hefty transfer fee and wages. Described as "worse than Anthony Gordon," this player has been "dreadful" in recent outings, with shocking stats in passes completed, tackles won, and goals contributed. Pundits and fans alike call for his axing, arguing he disrupts team balance and lacks the fight needed against Palace's counter-attacking style led by their resurgent forwards.

Howe must prioritize dynamism, potentially shifting to a **high-pressing 4-3-3** with reliable performers like Joelinton, Schär, and Woltemade, who shone in recent matches. The flop's benching would signal no room for complacency amid a congested schedule including Leeds United midweek and FA Cup ties[1][2].

Failure to act risks dropping points at home, derailing Newcastle's ambitious campaign. Howe's bold call could define their season. With St. James' Park roaring, axing the underperformer is non-negotiable for victory[3][4].

(Word count: 298)